Welcome: Henan Sinowin Chemical Industry Co.,Ltd.
Language: Chinese ∷  English
Your location: Home > News

News

Advantages & Disadvantages: Zinc Dust Process VS Sodium Formate Process

                                                                          Sodium Hydrosulfite

                                      Advantages & Disadvantages: Zinc Dust Process VS Sodium Formate Process

Zinc Dust Process

Advantages

1,Higher product purity, normally ≥98%, and better storage stability. It performs steadily in bleaching and gives good whiteness. Preferred by long-term customers for high-grade textile and silk bleaching.

2,Mature reaction system with fewer impurities, easier process control.

3,Less methanol consumption and lower solvent recovery burden.

Disadvantages

1,High raw material cost due to expensive zinc dust, overall production cost is much higher.

2,Heavy environmental drawbacks: generates large quantities of zinc-containing sludge and heavy-metal wastewater. Subject to strict REACH rules and carbon border adjustment risks; many countries restrict imports of zinc-based sodium hydrosulfite.

3,Longer production flow with multiple units, higher energy consumption and larger plant footprint.

4,Zinc hydroxide sludge can be recycled, yet the recovery process is complicated and the hazardous waste disposal cost is high.

 

Sodium Formate Process (Mainstream for export from China)

Advantages

1,Cost-competitive. Sodium formate is low-cost. Short continuous production line supports large-scale capacity, suitable for bulk export orders.

2,Cleaner production, no heavy metal waste. Only CO₂ emission and recyclable methanol. Easier to meet overseas ESG and environmental audit requirements.

3,Lower energy consumption and high sulfur yield. Methanol can be recycled.

Disadvantages

1,Purity and thermal stability are slightly lower, typical range 90–97%. More sensitive to decomposition during transport and storage; strict sealing & moisture-proof packaging is required. Bleaching performance is inferior to zinc-grade unless formulation is optimized.

2,Methanol solvent system leads to higher investment on explosion prevention and methanol recovery facilities.

3,Narrow operating window for pH, temperature and pressure; improper control causes quality fluctuation.

sodium hydrosulfite  (2).jpg



Service

Share

Phone

Inquiry

Qrcode

Top

Scan the qr codeClose
the qr code